Rest In Peace Major Winters and To The Pacific and beyond

I read in the news this week that Major Richard Winters of the 101st Airborne Division passed away (actually, he passed away on Jan. 2nd but gave instructions to his wife not to publish the information until after the burial). If you haven’t read Stephen Ambrose’s “Band of Brothers” (BoB) and you’re a military history buff like me, I’m appalled. Whatever your feelings are about Stephen Ambrose (there have been both unsubstantiated and substantiated claims about plagiarism), this is an excellent read. It’s definitely in my top 10 of all time and #2 on my military history books. #1 would be Cornelius Ryan’s “The Longest Day”. And the mini series on HBO was just as awesome. The book and mini series focus on Easy Company and their battles in WWII from training at Camp Toccoa through Normandy, Battle of the Bulge, and to capturing the Eagles Nest in Berlin. Ambrose does an excellent job in getting the reader to personally invest on each mission and the plethora of men in the company.

One of these men was Major Richard Winters. This book made me a huge fan of Major Winters. Not only was he an exceptional military strategist, but a great leader (and his men thought the same based on their accolades). If you know anything about WWII and European campaign, its success was a mixture of brilliant strategy and amazing luck (but I hazard a guess that most people in the military will say most battles are like that). But for me, this book brings the most human perspective to viewing a battle than most other books out there and Major Winters is a large reason. I actually went on to read “Beyond Band of Brothers: The War Memoirs of Major Dick Winters” and “Biggest Brother: The Life of Major Dick Winters, the Man who Led the Band of Brothers” by Larry Alexander. I would also recommend both those books. Both give you excellent insight into Major Winters and made me even more in awe of him. After surviving the Normandy invasion (D-Day), Major Winters is quoted as promising to himself that after the war, “he would settle down in some quiet place and live the remainder of his life in peace.” (Larry Alexander’s book, pg. 19). Well, Rest in Peace Major Winters, you definitely deserve it.

Other members of Easy Company went on to also write books detailing their personal and company’s treks through the war. Don Malarkey, William “Wild Bill” Guarnere & Edward “Babe” Heffron, and David Kenyon Webster are the ones I know. If you know of any others, I would definitely be interested in checking them out.

The Band of Brothers mini series was done by Tom Hanks and Steven Spielberg who also bring you “The Pacific”, which focuses on the WWII campaign in the Pacific. I’m only halfway through that mini series and I’m really on the fence about it. I’m personally very weak in knowledge of the Pacific campaign (much stronger on the European campaign and this weakness is something I’m trying to fix this year so if anyone knows of excellent books that cover this topic, please let me know!) but this series seems to be more about drama than facts and I felt like it was the opposite with BoB (more about facts and less drama). I’m not personally invested in the characters yet (I think I’m getting there with the kid who had the heart murmur and was delayed in enlisting but not yet). And I’m 99% certain that the battle of Guadalcanal didn’t last two or three spurts of furious gun battle but the series made it feel like it really wasn’t that big of deal (if I remember correctly, it was 4 months of grueling guerrilla-type battle but I might be wrong). The Battle of the Bulge lasted a bit but BoB did a good job of making you understand that they had been out in the cold and snow for months. I wish they could have taken the same care and detail with The Pacific that they did with BoB but I guess I can’t have everything I want…did anyone else see it? How far off the mark am I?

Well, I’m supposed to be studying (thanks to the IIA’s new rules, I basically have 9 days to start studying (which I finally did today), take and pass the test and if I have to retake it, it’s now going to cost a whopping $325 but I digress with disgust) so I’m hoping to pass the test and spend the rest of my year reading so any suggestions are welcome!

Advertisements

About jenvolk5

Bank auditor by day, trivia and knowledge hound all other times.
This entry was posted in Book Reviews and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Rest In Peace Major Winters and To The Pacific and beyond

  1. Jeffrey McMeans says:

    I read your comment about you being weak on The Pacific aspect of WW2 and you have come to the right place for some information. My father, Bud McMeans, was in the original US Navy SeaBees, fighting and constucting airfields all over the place, starting with Saipan, Tinian, and Okinawa.
    But, his son, me, has made a point out of figuring out the whole World War Two, but especially in the Pacific.
    So, start with two volume The Rising Sun by John Toland.
    then, you might read Day of Infamy(Dec. 7th, 1941) and Incredible Victory(the Battle of Midway) and then that will get you to Guadalcanal, my specialty. I can exhaust you with books on this battle and here is why; this battle started august 7, 1942 and ended
    on February 9th, 1943, three weeks after I was born. I would start right off there with Guadalcanal Diary by Richard Tregaskis and this is just touching the surface. I will fill you in with more titles as you want them.
    I can’t help myself. I am retired and my last 25-30 years has been studying all aspects of WW2, but am now focusing in on the Pacific because it was just huge.
    I could go on and on.
    Hope to hear from you,
    Jeffrey McMeans, USNR, 1961-1963
    jefreemcm@yahoo.com
    I scour used book stores in my vicinity and score a lot of titles cheap through amazon.com.

  2. Jeffrey McMeans says:

    One last thought; I watched 6 of the 10 episodes of The Pacific and then quit watching as it hurt so much because when you know what really happened and then see what Hollywood does to it, it leaves you flat, so you were close to the mark with your feelings.
    Growing up, I watched every World War 2 movie possible(and in the 50’s, there were hundreds)but after I started studying it, I could watch no more.
    I loved Cornelius Ryan’s The Longest Day also(and have an autographed copy of it. I am not bragging when I say I have easily 500 titles on WW2. I am a collector and that is that.

    • jenvolk5 says:

      Thanks for the book suggestions – I’m adding them to my list today!! And I’m glad I’m not the only one who felt that way about The Pacific – I actually only made it halfway through the fifth episode!! 🙂

  3. Jeffrey McMeans says:

    I will send more suggestions. It was late last night that I saw your blog and wanted to quickly respond to it. Here are a couple of websites to friends of mine. Peter Flahavin has made 8 trips to Guadalcanal from Melbourne, Australia, his home. He knew Martin Clemens, the Coastwatcher who alerted us that the Japs were building an airstrip on The Canal. Martin’s book, Alone on Guadalcanal is a classic from a real hero. http://guadalcanal.homestead.com/index.html
    Orv Iverson went ashore on Omaha Beach on D plus 3. He would have gone in the first wave, but…………. http://home.earthlink.net/~iversonom/index.html
    More later.
    Jeffrey

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s